Lesson 6 · Interrogatives

Four stems, thirty-two questions

Thirty-four lines on the day's sheet, and thirty-two of them are questions. They are not thirty-two things to learn: every one begins with one of four sounds, and almost every one is a shorter word you already have with something ordinary stuck on the end. The remaining two lines are not questions at all — they are the answers that arrived alongside them.

≈17 minutes · every reading checked against Jisho.org · the sets after Tofugu

Lesson 6 of the course

Five lessons of characters and words, and nothing yet that asks for anything back. This one is entirely question words — and it is the first lesson where the right move is not to memorise the list.

1.The first sound tells you it is a question

Sort the thirty-two by their opening sound and there are four piles, and nothing outside them:

StemAsksWords on this page
ど
do
which? — pick one out of a set that both of us can see 12
なに · なん
nani · nan
what? — no set, nothing to pick from, open 15
だれ
dare
who? — neither pattern, plus one compound 2
い
i
how many? how much? when? — not identity at all, but a quantity 3

The table counts opening sounds, so is filed under here even though the word cards in section 6 group it with the other ways of asking about people. Sounds for finding a word, jobs for using one.

Trick 1 · You know it is a question before the word ends

A Japanese sentence puts its verb last, so you often wait a long time to find out what is happening. Question words are the exception: the very first mora announces itself. Hear and something is about to be picked out of a set; hear and the field is wide open; hear and a number is wanted. You can start assembling an answer before the speaker has finished asking.

Arabic gives you no such warning. مَنْ, مَا, مَتَى, أَيْنَ, كَيْفَ, كَمْ and أَيّ share no opening letter and no pattern — each one has to be known on its own. Japanese charges you two syllables and hands back the whole set.

and are not new: both were word cards in lesson 5, filed under people and under town. Today they go to work.

2.Six of them come with three free relatives

Six of the twelve -words are not standalone vocabulary at all. Each is the last member of a set of four called — the name is just the four opening kana read in order. The set works like this:

The rest of the word — the ending — says what kind of thing is being pointed at. Prefix and ending are fully independent, which is what makes the grid below a grid rather than a list. Tap any cell to hear it.

The grid needs JavaScript. The same seven sets are laid out on the question-word reference sheet.

Trick 2 · Learn a row, not a word

Read the grid across and you learn an ending; read it down and you learn a distance. Twenty-eight words, seven endings and four prefixes — so the honest amount of new material here is eleven items, not twenty-eight. When you meet an unknown -word later, chop off the first mora and look for the row.

Two members refuse to be predicted, and both are marked in the grid: is not , and is not . Both irregulars are in the column, and neither is a -word, so nothing you need today is affected.

Why the polite one is the long one

Two of today's words are marked polite, and both are the longer member of a pair: → , and → . That is not a coincidence to be memorised twice. It is one rule that runs through the whole language.

Trick 3 · Politeness is distance, and distance costs syllables

The polite form asks something slightly beside the point. asks a direction rather than a place; comes from the row that gave modern Japanese , “you”. Refusing to point straight at the thing is what makes it courteous, and the extra mora is what you pay for it. Expect this everywhere: when two Japanese words mean the same thing, the longer one is the politer one.

Arabic does the same and you already do it without thinking — مَنْ حَضْرَتُكَ؟ is longer than مَنْ أَنْتَ؟ for exactly this reason.

There is an eighth set the grid leaves out: · · · , a casual contraction of the row and very common in speech. It needs the small , which this course has not taught yet, so it is named here and drilled later.

3.Every long one is short ones stuck together

Eight words on the list are longer than the rest, and not one of them is a new word. Each is a question word you have already met plus a piece of ordinary Japanese:

WordIsPlusAnd means
どうして
dōshite
どう
dōhow
して shite“doing”, from suru, to do why
どうやって
dōyatte
どう
dōhow
やって yatte“doing”, from yaru, to do by what method
どういう
dō iu
どう
dōhow
いう iuto say what sort of
どのぐらい
dono gurai
どの
donowhich
ぐらい gurairoughly, about how much, how long
どこの
doko no
どこ
dokowhere
の noof — links two nouns of where
なんの
nan no
なん
nanwhat
の noof — links two nouns of what
なんで
nan de
なん
nanwhat
で deby means of, with by what — and, in speech, why
だれと
dare to
だれ
darewho
と towith with whom

When you would actually say one

Taking a word apart is only useful if you can then put it somewhere. Here is each of the eight in the situation it belongs to — a real moment, and the sentence that goes in it.

WordThe momentWhat you say
どうして
dōshite
Someone tells you something and you want the reason どうしてですか。
dōshite desu kaWhy?
どうやって
dōyatte
A character or a machine is in front of you and you do not know how to work it これは どうやって よみますか。
kore wa dōyatte yomimasu kaHow do you read this?
どういう
dō iu
You have met a word or a sign you do not understand これは どういう いみですか。
kore wa dō iu imi desu kaWhat does this mean?
どのぐらい
dono gurai
You need an amount — a length, a time, a distance やすみは どのぐらいですか。
yasumi wa dono gurai desu kaHow long is the break?
どこの
doko no
You are holding a thing and want to know where it came from これは どこの くるまですか。
kore wa doko no kuruma desu kaWhat make is this car?
なんの
nan no
You can see the thing but not what it is about これは なんの ほんですか。
kore wa nan no hon desu kaWhat kind of book is this?
だれと
dare to
Someone mentions doing something and you want to know who with だれとですか。
dare to desu kaWho with?
なんで
nan de
The same question as , among people you are relaxed with なんでですか。
nan de desu kaWhy? / How come?

The tail tells you what has to come next

That is the use of knowing the seam, and it is not a curiosity. Knowing a word means knowing where it is allowed to sit, and for all seven of these the tail is what says so:

The other words on this page

Those sentences carry words the course has not formally taught. None of them is the point of the lesson — they are there so the question words have something to ask about — but you should not have to guess at them. Every one is readable with the characters you already have.

Three of them are not vocabulary at all. They are the machinery that turns words into a sentence, and Arabic does each job a different way — which is worth seeing, because it is why a Japanese sentence looks so unlike an Arabic one:

PieceWhat it doesArabic does it by
は
wa
Marks the topic — “as for ___”. Written , said wa. Nothing. Arabic marks the topic by putting it first and making it definite — اَلْكِتَابُ جَدِيدٌ.
です
desu
“is, am, are”, politely. Japanese needs it. Dropping it. هٰذَا كِتَابٌ is literally “this book” and means “this is a book”.
か
ka
Turns a statement into a question. Goes on the end. هَلْ or أَ — at the front, not the end.

The rest are ordinary words:

WordMeansArabicWhere from
これ
kore
this one هٰذَا
hādhā
Section 2, today
あの
ano
that … over there ذٰلِكَ
dhālika
Section 2, today
ひと
hito
person شَخْصٌ
shakhṣ
Lesson 4
ほん
hon
book كِتَابٌ
kitāb
Lesson 4
くるま
kuruma
car سَيَّارَةٌ
sayyāra
New here
いみ
imi
meaning مَعْنًى
maʿnan
New here
やすみ
yasumi
break, rest, holiday اِسْتِرَاحَةٌ
istirāḥa
New here
いま
ima
now اَلْآنَ
al-ān
New here
あした
ashita
tomorrow غَدًا
ghadan
New here
おてあらい
otearai
toilet, washroom — literally “the hand-washing place” دَوْرَةُ الْمِيَاهِ
dawratu l-miyāh
New here
よみます
yomimasu
reads — the polite form of , to read يَقْرَأُ
yaqraʾu
New here — borrowed whole

And three verbs you have not used but have already met, because their -forms are the tails in the table above: suru, to do in the general sense (يَفْعَلُ); yaru, to do in the hands-on sense (يَعْمَلُ); and iu, to say (يَقُولُ). Learn them as words now and the compounds stop being opaque.

Trick 4 · Never store a compound; store the seam

Learn eight words and you have eight words. Learn five tails — , , , , and the -form that and are — and you get these eight today plus an open-ended set later. joins any two nouns, turns any noun into “with that”, turns any noun into “by means of that”, and makes any quantity approximate.

The -form is the best of the four and you have just met it without being told: is it for (“to do”), for (also “to do”, more hands-on). It is the shape that lets a Japanese verb attach to anything else, and you will use it every day for years.

Three ways to say why

The day's sheet hands you three words for “why”, which looks like generosity and is actually a decision you now have to make every time. They are not interchangeable, and the difference is register far more than meaning:

WordWhere it belongsWhat else it can mean
なぜ
naze
Writing, and speech that is being careful. The formal one. Nothing. It is the only one of the three that can never be misread.
どうして
dōshite
Anywhere. The safe middle, and the one to reach for by default. Also “in what manner” — and native speakers sometimes have to ask which was meant.
なんで
nan de
Friends, family, anyone you are relaxed with. Blunt in the wrong room. Literally “by what means”, which is where the “why” came from in the first place.

Set against those, is the easy one: it can only mean “by what method”. It cannot be misread at all, so use it freely. That is the asymmetry worth holding on to — is narrow and safe; is broad and occasionally ambiguous.

Arabic keeps all of this apart without effort, which makes it a useful place to stand: لِمَاذَا for the plain reason, لِأَيِّ سَبَبٍ for the formal one, لِمَ for the short and casual one, and بِأَيِّ طَرِيقَةٍ for the method. Four Arabic phrases, four Japanese words, and they line up.

Arabic builds the same thing back to front

Five of the eight have an Arabic partner made the same way and assembled in mirror image — Arabic glues a preposition to the front, Japanese glues a particle to the back:

JapaneseArabicMade of
どうして
dōshite
لِمَاذَالِ + مَاذَا
どうやって
dōyatte
بِأَيِّ طَرِيقَةٍبِ + أَيّ
どこの
doko no
مِنْ أَيْنَمِنْ + أَيْنَ
だれと
dare to
مَعَ مَنْمَعَ + مَنْ
なんで
nan de
بِمَاذَابِ + مَاذَا

and مَعَ مَنْ are the identical construction written in opposite order. Japanese word order is not arbitrary once you see that — it is Arabic's, reversed, consistently.

Write with the . It is four beats, and dropping it is the usual beginner's slip.

4. asks how much, not which one

Three words on the sheet begin with neither nor , and they are the ones most likely to catch you out — because they are not asking you to identify anything. They want a number.

WordAsks forArabic
いつ
itsu
a time — any size, from a minute to a decade مَتَى
matā
いくつ
ikutsu
a count of things — and, of a person, their age كَمْ عَدَدًا
kam ʿadadan
いくら
ikura
a price, and essentially only a price بِكَمْ
bi-kam

Trick 5 · and are the same two characters

Both are written . Read them nan-ji and you have pinned the question to a clock face — “what hour”. Read them itsu and the unit is left open: the answer could be half past four, could be next March.

So the choice is not about politeness or formality, it is about how big the answer is allowed to be. If you do not know what unit it will come back in, ask . If you want a time on a clock, ask .

The other two share a different piece: (), an old word for “how many”. Put after it — the all-purpose counter for things — and you have . Put after it and you have , which counts money and nothing else. Two words, one stem, and the tail decides what is being counted.

The two lines on the sheet that are not questions

Thirty-four lines, thirty-two questions. The remaining two are what you say when somebody asks you one — and both are worth having on the same page as the questions they answer.

WordAnswersMade of
いつも
itsumo
“always” — the answer to いつ + も
“when” + “also, even”
ちょっと
chotto
“a little” — the answer to or when the answer is small Nothing. One of the very few words on this page with no parts at all.

Trick 6 · turns a question into “any”

is “when”. is “also, even”. Put them together and you get at any when — which is exactly what , “always”, means. Nothing has to be memorised; the word says what it is.

And this is not a one-off. The same works on the other stems: is “anyone”, is “everywhere”, is “anything”. You have not been taught those yet and there is a wrinkle waiting in how they behave with negatives — but when they arrive they will not be new words, they will be this rule again.

Write with the small . There is a rarer word with much the same meaning, but it is not the one in ordinary use.

also contains the small , which this course has still not taught — the same character that kept out of the grid in section 2. It is now the only thing left blocking, and it is one character.

5. plus a unit is the whole time system

Fifteen words carry the stem, and eleven of them are one frame with a different unit dropped into it. Take the six that name a point first, in this order, and they stop being six words and become one word and a clock:

WordUnitAsksArabic
なんねん
nannen
yearwhat yearأَيُّ سَنَةٍ
なんがつ
nangatsu
monthwhat monthأَيُّ شَهْرٍ
なんにち
nannichi
daywhat dateكَمْ يَوْمًا
なんようび
nan'yōbi
weekdaywhat day of the weekأَيُّ يَوْمٍ
なんじ
nanji
hourwhat timeكَمِ السَّاعَةُ
なんぷん
nanpun
minutehow many minutesكَمْ دَقِيقَةً

One more uses the same frame and has nothing to do with the clock at all: nannin, “how many people” (كَمْ شَخْصًا). The frame does not care what you drop into it, which is the whole point of a frame.

Trick 7 · Store them in the order Japanese writes a date

Japanese dates run large to small — year, then month, then day — the opposite of the English habit and the same as an ISO timestamp. The six words above are in exactly that order, and the order is free storage: recite once as a descending scale and you have the sequence for life. Rehearsing them alphabetically, or in the order they happen to appear on a sheet, throws that away.

Two of these show older lessons still working. is + , and the takes a maru because it lands directly after — which is the rule lesson 5 gave for where maru kana are allowed to live, happening in front of you. is the tenten doing the same job on .

A point in time, and a stretch of it

Every word above asks which — which year, which hour. None of them asks how long. The remaining four words on the sheet are how you ask that, and they are not new words at all.

Trick 8 · is the gap between, and it turns a point into a stretch

is — a gap, an interval, the space between two things. Hang it on the end of a time question and the question stops pointing at a moment and starts measuring a distance:

Point — أَيُّStretch — كَمْ
なんじ
nanjiwhat o'clock
なんじかん
nanjikanhow many hours
なんねん
nannenwhat year
なんねんかん
nannenkanhow many years
— なんしゅうかん
nanshūkanhow many weeks

Two units refuse to play along, and both are worth knowing as exceptions rather than discovering as mistakes:

Arabic makes the identical cut and makes it with two different words, which is why this is easier to hold from the Arabic side than from the English: أَيُّ سَنَةٍ is “which year”, كَمْ سَنَةً is “how many years”. Where Japanese adds , Arabic switches أَيُّ for كَمْ. Same distinction, two ways of drawing it.

has no dictionary entry of its own, and neither does or from section 3. That is the same fact each time: a dictionary does not list a phrase the language can generate. It also needs the small — lesson 7.

When it is and when it is

One character, , with a short form . Which one you say is decided by the sound that follows, not by the meaning, and the rule is short:

SayWhen the next thing isExample
なん
nan
a counter, or , or a word starting with t, d or n なんじ · なんですか · なんの
nanji · nan desu ka · nan no
なに
nani
anything else — a particle, or nothing at all なに? · なにが
nani? · nani ga

Trick 9 · Say both and let your mouth choose

There is nothing to memorise here, because the rule is not arbitrary. t, d and n are all made with the tongue tip against the ridge behind your teeth — and so is when something follows it. keeps the tongue in one place; makes it travel and come back. Say the wrong one aloud once and you will hear why nobody does.

The one place the ear does not help is a counter that starts with some other sound — , “how many times”. Counters take regardless. That is the only clause worth remembering as a rule.

The Arabic that maps onto this

Three of today's patterns have an exact partner in Arabic, which makes the translation direction in the drill much less work than it looks:

6.The thirty-four, as cards

Grouped the way the lesson argued for, not the way the sheet listed them: people first, then the six with a family, then the glued-together ones, then the words with their two answers, then and its counters. The note under a card is the structure it belongs to, so a card you have forgotten tells you which section to go back to.

The word cards need JavaScript. The same words, in the same groups, are on the question-word reference sheet.

Drill them for meaning

Three directions, as in lessons 4 and 5 — read it, produce it, and straight into Arabic. Wrong answers are drawn from inside the same group first, and with five groups instead of four that now lands almost entirely on the genuinely hard pairs:

If you can take those apart under time pressure you have the lesson.

The drill needs JavaScript. Every word it asks about is in the list above.

7.All of them, in one paragraph

Thirty-four cards is still thirty-four cards. Said in order, as one connected thing, it stops being a list and becomes a route — and the order below is the order this lesson has been arguing for all the way down: people, then the family, then , then and its counters. Reciting it walks the structure instead of the alphabet.

Read it aloud once a day, tapping any word to hear it. Each one carries its meaning in brackets, so nothing needs looking up, and the strip underneath lists all thirty-four in order for checking yourself against.

Then press Hide and read it again. The English stays; the Japanese and its meaning both come out of the sentences, leaving a gap the width of the word that was there. Now you have to produce each one yourself, which is the part that actually builds recall. Tap any gap to check that word alone without giving away the rest.

The paragraph needs JavaScript. The same thirty-four words, as cards, are in the section above.

This is the first scene of one day, every word — a walk that carries all 230 words the course has taught so far in fourteen of these, with the question words as the joints between scenes. This one is the doorway.

8.Put one in a sentence

A question word on its own is a flashcard. To use it you need one frame, and one is genuinely enough for everything below:

〜は 〜ですか。

marks what the sentence is about — read it wa, not ha, which is the single most useful irregularity in written Japanese. you already say every day: it is the tail of from lesson 1. Put the question word where the answer will go and the sentence is finished.

Every non-question word below is glossed in the other words on this page, with its Arabic.

  1. 1.What is this?

    Japanese

    これは なんですか。

    kore wa nan desu ka

    Arabic

    مَا هٰذَا؟

    mā hādhā

    The most useful sentence in the language while you are still learning it — and a live demonstration of section 4: , not , because begins with a d.

  2. 2.Who is that person?

    Japanese

    あのひとは だれですか。

    ano hito wa dare desu ka

    Arabic

    مَنْ ذٰلِكَ الشَّخْصُ؟

    man dhālika sh-shakhṣ

    Both grid words in one sentence: from the row, asking. Swap for and the same sentence becomes polite.

  3. 3.Where is the toilet?

    Japanese

    おてあらいは どこですか。

    otearai wa doko desu ka

    Arabic

    أَيْنَ دَوْرَةُ الْمِيَاهِ؟

    ayna dawratu l-miyāh

    The polite version swaps in , and in a hotel or a shop that is what you will hear back.

  4. 4.What time is it now?

    Japanese

    いま なんじですか。

    ima nanji desu ka

    Arabic

    كَمِ السَّاعَةُ الْآنَ؟

    kami s-sāʿatu l-ān

    No after — a time word can sit at the front of a sentence without being marked. That is the only exception to the frame you need today.

  5. 5.What day is tomorrow?

    Japanese

    あしたは なんようびですか。

    ashita wa nan'yōbi desu ka

    Arabic

    مَا هُوَ يَوْمُ الْغَدِ؟

    mā huwa yawmu l-ghad

    Change one unit and you change the question: asks the date, the month. Same frame, same particle.

  6. 6.What does this mean?

    Japanese

    これは どういう いみですか。

    kore wa dō iu imi desu ka

    Arabic

    مَا مَعْنَى هٰذَا؟

    mā maʿnā hādhā

    Worth having ready before you need it. is “meaning”, and takes the noun straight after it, exactly like .

  7. 7.How long is the break?

    Japanese

    やすみは どのぐらいですか。

    yasumi wa dono gurai desu ka

    Arabic

    كَمْ تَدُومُ الِاسْتِرَاحَةُ؟

    kam tadūmu l-istirāḥa

  8. 8.Why?

    Japanese

    どうしてですか。

    dōshite desu ka

    Arabic

    لِمَاذَا؟

    li-mādhā

    A whole sentence with nothing in front of the question word. Most of today's list will do this — say it alone, add , and it is polite and complete.

  9. 9.How much is this?

    Japanese

    これは いくらですか。

    kore wa ikura desu ka

    Arabic

    بِكَمْ هٰذَا؟

    bi-kam hādhā

    The first sentence you will actually need in a shop, and the reason is worth learning before .

  10. 10.How many hours is the break?

    Japanese

    やすみは なんじかんですか。

    yasumi wa nanjikan desu ka

    Arabic

    كَمْ سَاعَةً تَدُومُ الِاسْتِرَاحَةُ؟

    kam sāʿatan tadūmu l-istirāḥa

    Compare sentence 7, which asked the same thing with . That one leaves the unit open; this one demands the answer in hours. Swap for and you are suddenly asking what time the break starts — one syllable, a different question.

  11. 11.Why? — among friends

    Japanese

    なんでですか。

    nan de desu ka

    Arabic

    لِمَ؟

    lima

    Sentence 8 with the register changed, which is the only difference between them. Say this one to a friend and to anyone else — and if you are writing it down, .

9.Sources

  1. Tofugu, “Japanese Demonstratives: ” — the clearest account of the four-by-nine system anywhere free, with a separate page per set. Read this one: section 2 here is its opening argument compressed, and the pages it links to carry the usage detail this lesson had no room for.
  2. Jisho.org, serving JMdict/EDICT — every reading and gloss on this page, and the check that established is not a word while is. Keep it open while studying; it takes kana directly.
  3. The Japanese Page, “When to use and ” — the counter-and-t/d/n rule in section 4, stated as a rule with the exceptions named honestly.
  4. NHK World — Easy Japanese — free lessons with native recordings. Question sentences carry a rising intonation that speech synthesis flattens; this is the place to hear it done properly.
  5. Vance, T. J. (2008), The Sounds of Japanese, Cambridge University Press — why assimilates to the consonant after it, which is the whole mechanism behind → and behind → .
  6. Madinah Arabic and Almaany — the Arabic question words and their harakat.
  7. Question-word reference sheet — the grid and all thirty-four words, laid out to print. Its companions are the tenten and maru sheet and the hiragana stroke chart.
  8. One day, every word — the walk section 7 opens. Fourteen scenes, all 230 words taught so far, each of them in exactly one scene. It is the only page in the course that is meant to be read straight through, and it is the one to use when the problem is not “what does this word mean” but “which words do I actually know”.